Gender Affirming Care

GENDER AFFIRMING CARE FOR MINORS

INTRO & DISCLAIMER

• •
  Studies on regret, detransition, persistence, and satisfaction rates
• •
  Research on mental health, suicidality, and overall well-being after treatment
• •
  Risks associated with denying or delaying care
• •
  Information on puberty blockers, hormone replacement therapy (HRT), surgeries, and their effects
• •
  Critiques and opposing studies, including methodological weaknesses, limitations, and how those arguments are commonly addressed.

• •
  Regret after gender-affirming surgery/medical care is consistently reported as rare, often around 1%
• •
  Longitudinal youth studies generally show high persistence and continuation-of-care rates
• •
  Access to puberty blockers and hormones has been associated in multiple studies with reduced depression and suicidality
• •
  Most detransition cases reported in large surveys cite external pressures (family rejection, stigma, discrimination, finances, safety concerns) rather than no longer identifying as transgender
• •
  Existing research still has limitations, especially regarding long-term youth outcomes and randomized controlled data

OPENING STATEMENT:

KEY OBJECTIONS:

"Children are too young to make life long choices/children cannot consent!"

IMPORTANT STUDIES AND SOURCES:

REGRET & SATISFACTION

Levels of Satisfaction and Regret With Gender-Affirming Medical Care in Adolescence

Methodology

• •
  Longitudinal survey study
• •
  Used self and parent reporting
• •
  Measured satisfaction, regret, and continuation of care

Findings

• •
  Vast majority remained satisfied
• •
  Regret was rare (~4%)
• •
  97% continued gender-affirming care

Limitations

• •
  Mostly self-reported data
• •
  Not a random national sample
• •
  Majority of participants were White

Reidentification With Birth-Registered Sex in a Western Australian Pediatric Gender Clinic Cohort

Methodology

• •
  Prospective longitudinal study
• •
  Participants completed regular mental health surveys
• •
  Measured depression, anxiety, suicidality, regret, and continuation of care over time

Findings

• •
  Depression and anxiety symptoms declined over 2 years
• •
  Suicidal thoughts also decreased
• •
  97% continued gender-affirming care years later
• •
  About 4% (9 participants) reported some level of regret
• •
  Only 4 participants stopped all gender-affirming medical care entirely

Limitations

• •
  No randomized control group
• •
  Mostly self-reported data
• •
  Participants were already connected to gender clinics
• •
  Follow-up limited to 2 years

A critical commentary on follow-up studies and "desistance" theories about transgender and gender-nonconforming children

Methodology

• •
  Literature review of prior studies on transition outcomes
• •
  Focused on rates of regret after medical transition
• •
  Reviewed psychological, surgical, and social outcomes

Findings

• •
  Regret after transition was found to be rare across most studies
• •
  Many reported detransition cases were linked to external pressures like family rejection, discrimination, or lack of support rather than a change in gender identity itself
• •
  The review argued that improved assessment and support systems can help reduce regret further

Limitations

• •
  Review relied on older studies with varying definitions of "regret" and "detransition"
• •
  Some studies had small sample sizes or inconsistent follow-up periods
• •
  Much of the available research focused on adults rather than adolescents
• •
  Long-term modern data on youth transition was still limited at the time

2015 Transgender Survey

Methodology

• •
  Surveyed over 27,000 transgender adults across the US
• •
  Self-reported questionnaire study
• •
  Examined mental health, discrimination, medical transition, and quality of life

• •
  Most respondents who transitioned reported improved life satisfaction and psychological well-being
• •
  Access to hormones and surgery was associated with lower distress and higher overall functioning
• •
  Detransition was reported by a small minority of respondents
• •
  Among those who detransitioned, many cited external pressures like family rejection, discrimination, employment issues, or financial barriers rather than no longer identifying as trans

Limitations

• •
  Self-reported survey data
• •
  Not a randomized national sample
• •
  Cross-sectional survey rather than a long-term controlled study
• •
  Focused primarily on adults rather than adolescents

Factors Leading to "Detransition" Among Transgender and Gender Diverse People in the United States: A Mixed-Methods Analysis - PMC

Methodology

• •
  Secondary analysis of the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey
• •
  Looked at 17,151 trans adults who had pursued gender affirmation
• •
  Focused on people who reported a history of detransition

Findings

• •
  13.1% reported detransitioning at some point
• •
  82.5% cited at least one external reason
• •
  Common reasons included family pressure, social stigma, harassment, employment discrimination, and difficulty finding work
• •
  15.9% cited at least one internal reason, such as uncertainty or changes in gender identity
• •
  The study suggests detransition is often driven by outside pressure, not necessarily regret

Limitations

• •
  Self-reported survey data
• •
  Cross-sectional, so it cannot track changes over time
• •
  Does not prove why detransition happens in every case
• •
  Focused on adults, not youth

An analysis of all applications for sex reassignment surgery in Sweden, 1960-2010: prevalence, incidence, and regrets - PubMed

Methodology

• •
  Nationwide population study
• •
  Reviewed official Swedish medical records and surgery applications
• •
  Tracked long-term outcomes and requests to reverse legal/medical transition

Findings

• •
  Regret after transition was rare overall
• •
  15 people filed regret applications out of 767 individuals who underwent transition-related treatment, specifically bottom surgery (~2.2%)
• •
  Regret rates declined over time as standards of care improved
• •
  Researchers concluded that transition regret was uncommon in the Swedish population studied

Limitations

• •
  Based on Swedish healthcare data and may not generalize globally
• •
  Definitions of "regret" relied on formal reversal applications
• •
  Covered a long historical period with changing medical standards
• •
  Primarily focused on adults rather than adolescents

Regret after Gender-affirmation Surgery: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis of Prevalence - PMC

Methodology

• •
  Systematic review and meta-analysis
• •
  Reviewed 27 studies from multiple countries
• •
  Included approximately 7,900 transgender patients who underwent gender-affirming surgery
• •
  Examined prevalence and causes of surgical regret

Findings

• •
  Overall regret rate after surgery was about 1%
• •
  Regret rates were low for both trans men and trans women
• •
  Researchers concluded that regret after gender-affirming surgery is rare
• •
  Some regret cases were linked to social stigma, poor surgical outcomes, or lack of support

Limitations

• •
  Many studies had inconsistent definitions of "regret"
• •
  Follow-up periods varied widely
• •
  Some studies had high loss-to-follow-up rates
• •
  Most data came from adults, not adolescents
• •
  Researchers noted moderate-to-high risk of bias across several included studies

Gender Identity 5 Years After Social Transition | Pediatrics

Methodology

• •
  Longitudinal study of 317 transgender youth
• •
  Participants socially transitioned in childhood
• •
  Average starting age was about 8 years old
• •
  Researchers followed participants for 5 years using yearly surveys and follow-ups
• •
  Measured whether participants continued identifying as trans, reidentified with their sex assigned at birth, or identified as nonbinary

Findings

• •
  After 5 years, 94% still identified as transgender
• •
  About 3.5% reidentified with their sex assigned at birth
• •
  About 2.5% identified as nonbinary
• •
  Researchers concluded that gender identity remained highly stable for most socially transitioned youth in the study

Limitations

• •
  Participants came from supportive families and may not represent all trans youth
• •
  Mostly White and higher-income sample
• •
  Focused on socially transitioned children, not medical transition
• •
  Follow-up was limited to 5 years rather than an entire lifetime

BENEFITS & WELL-BEING

What does the scholarly research say about the effect of gender transition on transgender well-being? | What We Know

Methodology

• •
  Systematic review of peer-reviewed research
• •
  Reviewed studies on hormones, surgery, and social transition
• •
  Focused on mental health and quality-of-life outcomes

Findings

• •
  51 of 55 studies (93%) found transition improved well-being
• •
  4 studies found mixed or neutral results
• •
  No studies found overall harm from transition
• •
  Reported benefits included lower depression, anxiety, and suicidality

Limitations

• •
  Not a single original study — it's a review of existing research
• •
  Many underlying studies had small sample sizes
• •
  Research in trans healthcare is still developing
• •
  Limited long-term randomized controlled trials

Full article: Mental health and gender dysphoria: A review of the literature

Methodology

• •
  Review of 38 cross-sectional and longitudinal studies
• •
  Examined psychiatric outcomes, gender dysphoria, depression, anxiety, and suicidality
• •
  Reviewed outcomes before and after hormones, surgery, and social transition

Findings

• •
  Trans people had higher rates of mental health struggles compared to the general population, often linked to stigma and discrimination
• •
  Most studies found mental health outcomes improved after gender-affirming treatment
• •
  Gender dysphoria, depression, anxiety, and suicidality generally decreased following transition-related care
• •
  Researchers concluded available evidence supports gender-affirming approaches, while noting the need for stronger long-term research

Limitations

• •
  Many studies had small sample sizes
• •
  Research methods varied significantly between studies
• •
  Limited long-term prospective data
• •
  Many studies lacked strong control groups
• •
  Existing evidence at the time was considered moderate-to-low quality overall

Quality of life of treatment-seeking transgender adults: A systematic review and meta-analysis - PubMed

Methodology

• •
  Systematic review of 29 studies
• •
  Reviewed both cross-sectional and longitudinal research
• •
  Examined mental health, social functioning, and quality of life before and after treatment

Findings

• •
  Transgender people generally reported lower quality of life than the general population before treatment
• •
  Gender-affirming treatment was associated with improved quality of life in many studies
• •
  Improvements were commonly seen in social functioning, psychological well-being, and reduction of gender dysphoria
• •
  Researchers concluded evidence overall supports positive effects from gender-affirming care, though results varied between studies

Limitations

• •
  Many studies had small sample sizes
• •
  Research methods differed significantly between studies
• •
  Limited long-term longitudinal data
• •
  Some studies lacked strong control groups
• •
  Researchers noted overall evidence quality was moderate-to-low

Hormonal therapy and sex reassignment: a systematic review and meta‐analysis of quality of life and psychosocial outcomes - Murad - 2010 - Clinical Endocrinology - Wiley Online Library

Methodology

• •
  Systematic review and meta-analysis
• •
  Reviewed 28 studies with 1,833 transgender participants
• •
  Included people receiving hormone therapy as part of transition
• •
  Most included studies were observational

Findings

• •
  80% reported improved gender dysphoria
• •
  78% reported improved psychological symptoms
• •
  80% reported improved quality of life
• •
  72% reported improved sexual function
• •
  Researchers concluded transition-related treatment was generally associated with better psychosocial outcomes

Limitations

• •
  Evidence quality was rated "very low"
• •
  Most studies lacked control groups or randomization
• •
  Heavy reliance on self-reported outcomes
• •
  Difficult to isolate effects of hormones from surgery and psychotherapy
• •
  High variation between studies

Long-Term Follow-Up of Adults with Gender Identity Disorder - PubMed

Methodology

• •
  Long-term follow-up study
• •
  71 participants: 35 trans women and 36 trans men
• •
  Legal gender change had to be at least 10 years earlier
• •
  Follow-up period ranged from 10–24 years, averaging 13.8 years
• •
  Used clinical interviews, follow-up questionnaires, and standardized questionnaires

Findings

• •
  Participants reported high well-being
• •
  Participants showed good social integration
• •
  Overall results suggested positive long-term outcomes after transition

Limitations

• •
  Small sample size
• •
  Adult-only study
• •
  Not randomized or controlled
• •
  Participants had already legally transitioned, so it does not capture people who dropped out before that point
• •
  Older diagnostic language and treatment standards

Young Adult Psychological Outcome After Puberty Suppression and Gender Reassignment | Pediatrics

Methodology

• •
  Longitudinal Dutch study
• •
  Followed 55 transgender youth treated at a gender clinic
• •
  Participants first received puberty blockers during adolescence
• •
  Researchers tracked them from early treatment into young adulthood
• •
  Measured psychological functioning, gender dysphoria, and quality of life over time

Findings

• •
  Gender dysphoria improved significantly after treatment
• •
  Psychological functioning improved steadily across transition
• •
  By young adulthood, participants had mental health outcomes similar to or better than same-age peers in the general population
• •
  Researchers reported improved well-being and life satisfaction after transition-related care

Limitations

• •
  Small sample size (55 participants)
• •
  Conducted in the Netherlands within a specialized clinic
• •
  Participants underwent extensive psychological screening before treatment
• •
  No randomized control group
• •
  Results may not generalize to all healthcare systems or populations

Mental Health Outcomes in Transgender and Nonbinary Youths Receiving Gender-Affirming Care | Pediatrics | JAMA Network Open

Methodology

• •
  Prospective cohort study
• •
  Followed 104 transgender and nonbinary youth ages 13–20
• •
  Participants received care through the Seattle Children's Gender Clinic
• •
  Researchers tracked outcomes over 1 year
• •
  Measured depression, anxiety, and suicidality at regular follow-ups

Findings

• •
  Youth who received puberty blockers or hormones had 60% lower odds of moderate-to-severe depression
• •
  They also had 73% lower odds of suicidality/self-harm over 12 months
• •
  Researchers concluded gender-affirming medical care was associated with improved mental health outcomes

Limitations

• •
  Small sample size
• •
  No randomized control group
• •
  Follow-up limited to 1 year
• •
  Participants were already connected to a gender clinic, which may limit generalizability
• •
  Mostly self-reported mental health data

Association of Gender-Affirming Hormone Therapy With Depression, Thoughts of Suicide, and Attempted Suicide Among Transgender and Nonbinary Youth - Journal of Adolescent Health

Methodology

• •
  Cross-sectional survey study
• •
  Used data from The Trevor Project's 2021 National Survey
• •
  Data collected from October–December 2020
• •
  Included transgender and nonbinary youth ages 13–24
• •
  Compared youth receiving hormones to youth who wanted hormones but were not receiving them

Findings

• •
  14% were receiving hormone therapy
• •
  50% wanted hormones but were not receiving them
• •
  36% were not interested in hormones
• •
  Hormone therapy was linked to lower odds of recent depression and seriously considering suicide
• •
  For youth under 18, hormone therapy was linked to nearly 40% lower odds of recent depression and past-year suicide attempt

Limitations

• •
  Cross-sectional, so it cannot prove causation
• •
  Self-reported survey data
• •
  Not a randomized clinical sample
• •
  Measures association, not long-term outcomes
• •
  Does not directly measure regret or detransition

Association Between Gender-Affirming Surgeries and Mental Health Outcomes

Methodology

• •
  Secondary analysis of the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey
• •
  Included 27,715 transgender and gender-diverse adults across the US
• •
  Compared people who had undergone gender-affirming surgery at least 2 years earlier to people who wanted surgery but had not received it
• •
  Adjusted for demographics and other forms of gender-affirming care like hormones and counseling
• •
  Measured psychological distress, smoking, alcohol use, suicidal ideation, and suicide attempts

Findings

• •
  People who had surgery had significantly lower odds of severe psychological distress
• •
  They also had lower odds of smoking and suicidal ideation
• •
  Those who received all desired surgeries showed even stronger mental health improvements
• •
  Researchers concluded gender-affirming surgery was associated with improved mental health outcomes

Specific Results

• •
  12.8% had undergone at least one gender-affirming surgery
• •
  59.2% wanted surgery but had not received it
• •
  Surgery was associated with:
• •
  42% lower odds of severe psychological distress
• •
  35% lower odds of smoking
• •
  44% lower odds of suicidal ideation
• •
  Receiving all desired surgeries was associated with the strongest reductions in adverse mental health outcomes

Limitations

• •
  Cross-sectional observational study, so it cannot fully prove causation
• •
  Used self-reported survey data
• •
  Nonprobability sampling may limit generalizability
• •
  Did not directly measure regret or detransition
• •
  Potential for unmeasured confounding factors

Mental Health of Transgender Children Who Are Supported in Their Identities | Pediatrics

Methodology

• •
  Cross-sectional study
• •
  Included 73 socially transitioned transgender children ages 3–12
• •
  Compared them to two control groups:
• •
  73 age-matched cisgender controls
• •
  49 siblings of transgender participants
• •
  Parents completed standardized measures of depression and anxiety
• •
  Researchers analyzed mental health symptoms across groups

Findings

• •
  Transgender children showed no elevated rates of depression compared to controls
• •
  Anxiety levels were only slightly elevated relative to population averages
• •
  Depression scores were nearly identical to cisgender peers
• •
  Researchers concluded that socially supported transgender children showed "developmentally normative" mental health outcomes rather than the severe psychopathology often reported in older studies of unsupported gender dysphoric youth

Specific Results

• •
  Average depression score for trans children: 50.1 (population norm = 50)
• •
  Average anxiety score: 54.2, slightly above the population norm
• •
  No significant differences in depression between trans children and control groups

Limitations

• •
  Cross-sectional study, not long-term follow-up
• •
  Participants came from highly supportive families
• •
  Mostly White, higher-income sample
• •
  Relied on parent-reported measures
• •
  Focused on socially transitioned children, not medical transition

Pubertal Suppression for Transgender Youth and Risk of Suicidal Ideation - PMC

Methodology

• •
  Cross-sectional study using data from the 2015 U.S. Transgender Survey
• •
  Included 20,619 transgender adults ages 18–36
• •
  Researchers focused on 3,494 participants who reported wanting puberty blockers during adolescence
• •
  Compared people who received puberty blockers to those who wanted them but did not receive them
• •
  Measured lifetime suicidal ideation and psychological distress

Findings

• •
  Only 2.5% of participants who wanted puberty blockers had received them
• •
  Access to puberty blockers was associated with significantly lower odds of lifetime suicidal ideation
• •
  Participants who received puberty blockers had roughly 70% lower odds of lifetime suicidal ideation compared to those who wanted them but could not access them
• •
  Researchers concluded that access to pubertal suppression was associated with better mental health outcomes in adulthood

Specific Results

• •
  90.2% of participants who wanted but did not receive puberty blockers reported lifetime suicidal ideation
• •
  75.3% of those who received puberty blockers reported lifetime suicidal ideation
• •
  Adjusted odds ratio for lifetime suicidal ideation was 0.3

Limitations

• •
  Cross-sectional observational study, so it cannot prove causation
• •
  Relied on retrospective self-reported survey data
• •
  Very small number of participants actually received puberty blockers
• •
  Potential for recall bias and unmeasured confounding variables
• •
  Did not directly measure regret or detransition

RISKS OF IGNORED CARE

TREATMENTS & EFFECTS

Gender-Affirming Medications Among Transgender Adolescents in the US, 2018-2022

Methodology

• •
  Cross-sectional insurance claims study
• •
  Used commercial insurance data from 5,155,282 adolescents ages 8–17
• •
  Study period covered 2018–2022
• •
  Researchers identified youth with gender-related diagnoses and tracked prescriptions for puberty blockers and hormones

Findings

• •
  Fewer than 0.1% of adolescents in the database received gender-affirming medications
• •
  17,151 adolescents had a gender-related diagnosis
• •
  926 received puberty blockers
• •
  1,927 received gender-affirming hormones
• •
  No hormone prescriptions were identified for children under age 12
• •
  Researchers concluded gender-affirming medication use among adolescents was rare

Specific Results

• •
  Puberty blocker use peaked around ages 14–15
• •
  Hormone therapy use increased with age, especially among older adolescents
• •
  Rates remained low even among youth diagnosed with gender dysphoria

Limitations

• •
  Included only commercially insured adolescents, not uninsured or many Medicaid patients
• •
  Insurance claims data may undercount care received outside insurance systems
• •
  Cross-sectional administrative data cannot assess long-term outcomes
• •
  Did not examine regret, detransition, or mental health outcomes

STUDIES TO WATCH OUT FOR

What the Study Actually Looked At

The study measured

• •
  overall mortality
• •
  suicide death
• •
  suicide attempts
• •
  psychiatric inpatient care
• •
  substance misuse
• •
  accidents
• •
  criminal convictions

What the Study Found

Rapid Onset of Gender Dysphoria in Adolescents and Young Adults: a Descriptive Study

• •
  being transgender is a "social contagion"
• •
  teens are becoming trans because of peer pressure or the internet
• •
  adolescents are suddenly "deciding" they are trans without prior signs
• •
  modern increases in trans identification are caused by online influence rather than genuine gender dysphoria

Researchers did not interview

• •
  the adolescents themselves
• •
  clinicians treating the adolescents
• •
  or independently verify diagnoses

• •
  4thWaveNow
• •
  Transgender Trend
• •
  Youth Trans Critical Professionals

• •
  methodology
• •
  terminology
• •
  and interpretation of findings

Psychiatric Morbidity Among Adolescents and Young Adults Who Contacted Specialised Gender Identity Services in Finland in 1996–2019: A Register Study - Ruuska - Acta Paediatrica - Wiley Online Library

IMPORTANT NOTE:

Common Use of the Study

• gender-affirming care does not help mental health,

• transition fails,

• or gender dysphoria is primarily caused by mental illness.

• it was not a randomized controlled trial,

• it did not compare treated vs untreated youth,

• and it was not designed to determine whether gender-affirming care "works."

What the Study Found

• depression,

• anxiety,

• suicidality,

• trauma,

• and social stressors.

Major Limitation

So continued psychiatric struggles do not automatically mean:

• treatment caused harm,

• treatment failed,

• or outcomes would have been better without care.